India has the largest democracy in the world. After ruling the subcontinent for over
two hundred years, the British surrendered power and India became a free country.
India adopted the path of parliamentary democracy. The British parliamentary
system left a lasting impress on it; due to the colonial legacy the framers of the
Indian Constitution borrowed this system primarily from England. The freedom of
the judiciary was taken from the USA. The USA did impart considerable power to
the judiciary and made the judiciary free of the biased influence of the executive and
the legislature.
Parliamentary democracy, which is the basic foundation of our Constitutional setup,
presupposes the sovereignty of the people. As a prerequisite for a functional
parliamentary democracy, the Constitution of India has provided for’ ‘separation of
powers’ for securing the basic rights of the people. It lays down the structure and
defines the limits and demarcates the role and functions of every organ of the state,
including the judiciary, and establishes the norms for their inter-relationship, checks
and balances with a very important object of ensuring that the power is not
concentrated in any particular organ of the state, which can assume undesirable
proportions.
Independence of the judiciary is essential for upholding the rule of law. The grave
problem, however, that courts are often faced with is this: on the one hand, the
Constitution is the supreme law of the land and, on the other hand, in the garb of
interpreting the Constitution, the court must not seek an unnecessary confrontation
with the legislature, particularly since the legislature consists of representatives
democratically elected by the people. The court certainly has power to decide
constitutional issues. However, as pointed out by Justice Frankfurter in West
Virginia State Board of Education vs. Barnette 319 U.S. 624 (1943), since this great
power can prevent the full play of the democratic process, it is vital that it should be
exercised with rigorous self restraint. |